FemResThe Living Review
Mustang

Family Liberation · Screen

Mustang

A beach game leads to confinement for five sisters. Deniz Gamze Ergüven uses a football stand, a television and a house filling with bars to ask who gets to judge the girls.

Director
Deniz Gamze Ergüven
Year
2015
Region
Turkey / France / Germany / Qatar
Duration
97 min
Share this resource
X ↗Facebook ↗

Reading the film

In Deniz Gamze Ergüven’s Mustang, a game after school marks one of the last times five sisters can move freely through their village. They climb onto boys’ shoulders and play in the water. A neighbor reports them to their family. In the Cannes press-kit interview, Ergüven recalls being reprimanded after a similar incident as a teenager. She remembers lowering her eyes in shame. In the film, the girls get a chance to object. The difference matters because whoever gets to describe the game can turn ordinary contact into a reason to restrict the girls’ lives.

How a home becomes a prison

Confinement takes hold through schedules and objects. Cooking and sewing replace school. Bars spread across the windows. The grandmother and her relatives remove phones and other possessions. The French Lycéens et apprentis au cinéma study booklet notes a revealing cut from the grandmother locking a cupboard to Lale swatting flies. Lale still has tasks to carry out. The range of people she can reach and things she can do has suddenly narrowed. Ergüven compares the film’s dramatic structure to a prison escape. Watch when each barrier goes up and who can open the cupboard to see how punishment becomes an ordinary household routine.

Two weddings expose the different room the sisters have to bargain. Sonay insists on marrying the man she loves. Selma is married to someone chosen for her. When Selma does not bleed on her wedding night, her in-laws take her to a hospital to have a doctor assess her virginity. That scene extends the family’s claim over her body into a consulting room, where relatives seek professional authority for an intimate judgment. Watching the two weddings together makes it possible to ask what gives one sister leverage and how easily another can be denied authority over her own account.

A spell of freedom in the stands

The sisters slip away to a football match from which male spectators are barred. The study booklet records a cut from stamping feet on the way to the stadium to feet stamping in the stands. It also notes the slow motion as the sisters jump in delight. The repeated action carries the momentum of the journey into the crowd, and the slowed image makes room to dwell on their brief freedom together. Television then makes them visible back at home. Aunt Emine cuts the power before the girls’ uncle can see them. She also helps train them in household duties, so her moment of improvisation shows how one adult can enforce a rule and shield the girls from its consequences.

Ergüven likens the match to a fairy-tale ball and the sisters to a single body with five heads. The choice intensifies both the delight of the crowd and the pressure of confinement. Watch the beach, the stands and the television in sequence. At each point, someone else can give the girls’ actions a public meaning. Prayers for the Stolen offers a companion viewing. Its hiding places respond to armed violence in Mexico. In Mustang, restrictions grow around sexual reputation and marriage. Each film gives the home a different role in the entanglement of protection and control.

Reader responses

Discussion

Share your response and continue the reading together.

Join the Discussion

Responses

Loading comments...

Support Us

If you find our content valuable, please consider supporting FemRes.

Support FemRes