FemResThe Living Review
She Said

MeToo Movement · Screen

She Said

Maria Schrader places survivors’ voices, a former assistant’s settlement and a newsroom’s verification side by side to ask what makes testimony publishable.

Director
Maria Schrader
Year
2022
Region
USA
Duration
128 min
Share this resource
X ↗Facebook ↗

Reading the film

Listen to the voice and look at the room

Maria Schrader’s She Said follows New York Times reporters Jodi Kantor and Megan Twohey as they investigate Harvey Weinstein. Start with the passages set in hotels. A survivor’s account continues on the soundtrack while the camera looks at an empty room or corridor. Screenwriter Rebecca Lenkiewicz discusses that decision in a Writers Guild East interview. She also makes a point that bears on how the images are read: the hotel was a workplace. Doors, lamps and meeting places look ordinary while a voice describes how a meeting turned dangerous. Holding on such spaces gives the witness’s account room to unfold.

A second formal choice concerns the newsroom. Cinematographer Natasha Braier tells the American Society of Cinematographers that she kept many dialogue shots static so viewers could take in the information. Schrader recalls an exception in perspective: for the call in which Judd agrees to be named, she wanted to look into the office from the street. Watch how that window changes who is visible. The voice we hear comes from elsewhere, while a group of people is there to respond and do something with it.

Who gets to keep the record?

The meeting between Kantor and former assistant Zelda Perkins, played by Samantha Morton, follows a different kind of silence. On pages 83–86 of Universal’s production screenplay, Perkins explains that she signed a settlement she could not take away in copy. She tried to remember its terms. When prospective employers wanted to know why she had left her previous job, she felt unable to tell them. The arrangement therefore reaches beyond the settlement itself. It shapes whether a worker can explain her own career and who has the documents to verify what she says.

In their own account of the film, the reporters recall that editors backed them during confrontations with the company’s lawyers. The memory makes another part of verification visible. Someone with new evidence had a person to bring it to, and an institution willing to share the risk of acting on it. Put that alongside Perkins’s account of looking for work. Possessing records, agreeing to be named and having the means to publish are different kinds of power.

Near publication, Ashley Judd’s decision to be named sits alongside the newsroom’s work. Compare the 2017 investigation as published and look for what is attributed by name and what is corroborated through interviews or records. A film compresses verification and an investigation shows what could be published at the time. Tarana Burke on Me Too as a movement takes the reading past publication. What support is still available later to people who were asked to risk their jobs, a legal challenge or public doubt?

Explore another medium

Continue through the issues

Reader responses

Discussion

Share your response and continue the reading together.

Join the Discussion

Responses

Loading comments...

Support Us

If you find our content valuable, please consider supporting FemRes.

Support FemRes