FemResThe Living Review

Feminist Theory · Research

Higamous, hogamous, woman monogamous

Amanda Rees uses Ally McBeal, conviction data and comparisons with bonobos to ask how evolutionary accounts of sex and violence select their evidence.

00

Abstract

Rees examines evolutionary arguments about gender, parental investment and sexual violence. She separates proximate from ultimate explanation, asks what conviction data can establish and uses bonobo research to test comparisons across species.

Keywordsevolutionary psychologygender essentialismscience critiquemate selectionbiological determinism
Read the paper
Share this resource
X ↗Facebook ↗

01

Research notes

From Ally McBeal to the conviction record

On page 365 of the article, the accomplished women of Ally McBeal still face the idea that a partner is the real sign of success. Rees then quotes Michael Ghiglieri on economically independent women. The movement from television to popular science gives readers a chance to follow how an account of parental investment is made to explain contemporary choices. Mark three different things as you read: an event or conflict invented for television, a claim about why it happens and the observations that would help establish the claim. This lets you see where the distress of a fictional character starts doing the work of an observation about a population.

Pages 366–368 turn to Randy Thornhill and Craig Palmer’s evolutionary account of rape. Rees entertains the possibility that their account of victim blaming could lend support to some feminist criticism. She then asks a pointed question about the record. If young, poor men are prominent in conviction data, does the pattern come from who commits rape or who is more likely to be convicted? Try giving occurrence, reporting, investigation and conviction separate columns. A count at the end of that sequence has passed through several institutions. Note 4 on page 369 distinguishes proximate causes from ultimate explanations. A hypothesis about how a behavior might have emerged still leaves questions about why a particular event occurred and which cases make it into the record. Feminist social research can address these questions directly.

What changes when bonobos enter the comparison?

The bonobos on pages 368–369 raise a similar question about selection in comparisons across species. Rees discusses arguments that draw on aggression in gorillas, chimpanzees and orangutans to infer ancient origins of male violence. The primatology she cites describes another arrangement. Female bonobos also leave their natal groups, and they can establish strong bonds with females in the groups they join. Ask how the set of species being compared shapes the pattern that can be called common. Then turn to Rees’s use of Bruce Bagemihl. Same-sex behavior in animals had been documented, and whether it made its way into an explanation depended on what writers took sexual behavior to be for. Keep a list of which observations enter the comparison and which drop out.

The article belongs to a debate in 2000. Rees ends by asking what an evolutionary psychology that examines its own assumptions might offer feminist theory. The television account, courtroom records and animal observations give readers three chances to ask who selects the evidence, where it was recorded and how far it can take an explanation. A different animal example can test the breadth of an analogy. Local patterns of reporting and conviction require evidence about the institutions in that place.

Reader responses

Research discussion

Respond to this research or add another paper worth reading together.

Join the Discussion

Responses

Loading comments...

Support Us

If you find our content valuable, please consider supporting FemRes.

Support FemRes