Marxist Feminism · Research
Indexing alternatives: Feminist development studies and global political economy
Priti Ramamurthy maps feminist debates over development through six books. Companion readings trace agricultural work, basic needs and the cotton commodity chain.
Abstract
The opening on page 239 frames this as an intellectual history of feminism and development studies. Ramamurthy compares work by Boserup, Sen and Grown with two later edited collections and draws on two further readers. The journal provides the first page, notes and references.
Research notes
Which work enters the accounts of development?
The first page in Feminist Theory, page 239, lists six books and explains how to read them together. Ramamurthy puts classic works by Ester Boserup and by Gita Sen and Caren Grown beside each other, then compares both with collections edited by Marchand and Parpart and by Jackson and Pearson. Naila Kabeer’s overview and the reader edited by Nalini Visvanathan and colleagues open two more routes through the literature. This arrangement makes a question of how later writers inherit the scale at which earlier ones observed work, and how they change who can define the problem of development. Note 1 qualifies the broad sweep of the review and points to the need for histories grounded in specific societies, where the nation-state and nationalist politics have shaped the stakes.
Try Boserup’s first chapter beside Sen and Grown’s book for DAWN. On page 4, Boserup distinguishes subsistence farming systems by who mainly does the work. On page 42, she considers the promotion of men’s farming by European colonial authorities. On pages 50–52, Sen and Grown bring food, fuel and water into the same account. Aggregate output can grow while the conditions for households to meet basic needs deteriorate. Try drawing a table for each passage and adding entries for food output, time spent fetching water and access to land. A policy can acknowledge women’s agricultural work and still require them to spend more time keeping a household going.
From the name of a field to a cotton commodity chain
Note 9 in the journal distinguishes an earlier use of Gender and Development from the use of the same name by the World Bank, pointing out their different theoretical origins. Note 18 points readers to Hart’s research on household economies. A total income figure can show how much is available to a household. It takes evidence about bargaining within it to see who can draw on the money and who puts in extra hours of work. As you meet the term in the two settings, mark who defines the problem, what counts as evidence and who is supposed to act. The answers are more informative than a sequence of acronyms. Projects using the same name can assign the gains and the costs quite differently.
Ramamurthy’s separate study of the cotton commodity chain, included in the references, offers a worked example published the same year. On pages 557–558 it moves from small farms in southern India, where commercialization relied in part on unpaid work by women and children, to the Japanese mills. Family pressures sent some workers into the mills. Others saw leaving home as a chance to support themselves. Follow the cotton and the unpaid hours, wages and claims of the household come into the same view. This example comes from the cotton study. The accessible record of Indexing Alternatives provides the comparison proposed on the first page, the notes and the bibliography.
Explore another medium
- Books
All We Can Save
Ayana Elizabeth Johnson and Katharine K. Wilkinson
This climate anthology gathers women scientists, policy leaders, poets, and organizers, treating climate action as leadership, grief, and collective imagination.
Global Feminism · Social Movements - Articles
No Care Economies Without Domestic Workers!
AWID and domestic worker, labor and feminist movement contributors
An AWID co-created manifesto argues that a just care economy must recognize domestic workers’ labor rights and leadership, not treat care as an input to economic growth.
Feminist Economics · Social Movements
Reader responses
Research discussion
Respond to this research or add another paper worth reading together.
Join the Discussion
Loading comments...
Support Us
If you find our content valuable, please consider supporting FemRes.