FemResThe Living Review

Feminist Theory · Research

Book Review: Introduction to Feminist Jurisprudence

Jane Scoular reviews Hilaire Barnett’s feminist jurisprudence textbook. Start with the book’s examples of abortion debates and provocation before turning to the review.

00

Abstract

Bibliographic note. Jane Scoular reviews Hilaire Barnett’s Introduction to Feminist Jurisprudence, published in 1998. The review appears on pages 123–126 of the first issue of Feminist Theory. The journal lists the review and restricts access to its text.

Keywordsfeminist jurisprudencelegal theorygender and lawlegal reformlegal equality
Read the paper
Share this resource
X ↗Facebook ↗

01

Research notes

Who gets to decide? Start on page 21 of the textbook

The journal’s contents page lists Scoular’s review on pages 123–126 of the first issue. The listing is public. The reading route below follows the preview of Hilaire Barnett’s textbook. With access to the review, a reader can bring concrete questions to Scoular’s evaluation. How does she assess the arrangement of theory and cases? Where does she think students would need more help?

On pages 19–20 of the book, Barnett discusses consciousness raising through sharing experiences. Listen for the moment when an experience someone had to deal with alone starts to look like the effect of an institutional practice. Barnett also brings in Audre Lorde’s criticism of treating white women’s experiences as universal. On page 21, Barnett turns to the parliamentary debates preceding Britain’s Abortion Act 1967. She asks how speakers depicted women seeking abortions and the doctors whose professional standing informed the discussion. Try recording two things in the margin: how speakers characterized each group, and who could make a decision that would bind the person directly affected. This puts descriptions of rationality next to the allocation of decision-making power. The same comparison can expose who is absent from the account. Someone described by a legislator and someone who can testify in their own words enter the debate under different conditions.

From provocation on page 22 to Scoular’s own writing

On page 22, Barnett turns to the historical English partial defence of provocation. Through R v Ahluwalia and R v Thornton, she asks what a legal framework that expects a sudden reaction can make of someone’s experience of prolonged domestic violence. The preceding example gave a public language to the figure authorized to decide. Here a model of the legally intelligible response is built into the timing the law expects. Write down how the event is presumed to unfold and how long the situation faced by the defendant had developed. Read the legal discussion in the period and jurisdiction of the textbook.

Then try Scoular’s 1998 chapter on feminist jurisprudence. On page 62, Scoular links the former marital rape exemption to the way the law treated agreement to marry as continuing sexual consent. Read that passage alongside Barnett’s other examples and mark how professional authority, the timing of a response and marital status can each shape a legal judgment. The examples come from the textbook and Scoular’s chapter. The review on pages 123–126 is the place to look for Scoular’s specific appraisal of Barnett’s book.

Explore another medium

Continue through the issues

Reader responses

Research discussion

Respond to this research or add another paper worth reading together.

Join the Discussion

Responses

Loading comments...

Support Us

If you find our content valuable, please consider supporting FemRes.

Support FemRes