Feminist Theory · Research
More Power to Argument
Axeli Knapp tests how Walby connects argument, difference and action. This guide follows the dispute into the practical problem of comparing concepts across contexts.
Abstract
The article welcomes renewed attention to argument while questioning Walby’s use of Habermas, her different meanings of difference and her construction of oppositions between theories.
Research notes
What kind of question is an argument answering?
Axeli Knapp’s “More Power to Argument” appeared in Feminist Theory 1(2), 2000, pages 207–223. The journal makes the abstract available. It identifies a problem with the way Sylvia Walby’s opening article moves among epistemology, moral and political theory, and practical politics. Try putting a question next to each level. What evidence supports an account of inequality? What would count as a just arrangement? How could people organize to change the current arrangement? An answer can inform the question on the next line, but it takes an argument to make the connection. Journal record and abstract · Guide to Walby’s opening article
The abstract names three lines of inquiry. They concern Habermas’s account of argumentation, the meanings assigned to difference and how apparently opposing theories are put into camps. Test the distinction with an example from workplace bargaining. A cleaner’s account of a shift schedule that makes her less likely to qualify for benefits gives a researcher something to investigate. Revising the eligibility rules calls for a judgment about fairness. Getting the workers into a negotiation calls for knowing whether they can be released from shifts and choose who speaks for them. This is a reading exercise. Across the three questions, difference could mean a variation in experience, an unequal allocation of resources or a difference in who can change the terms of the decision.
What happens when a concept crosses a border?
On page 237 of her published reply, Walby understands the dispute as one about the standing of critical theory and the role of empirical evidence. In her reading, Knapp leaves too little room for empirically informed feminist analysis. She also acknowledges a point of agreement about the influence of social bias on theory production. Read this as Walby’s account, then return to Knapp’s abstract to ask what is at stake in the classification of theories. Each author can change the terms on which the other’s argument is heard. Walby’s complete published reply · Guide to the reply
Pages 71–74 of Knapp’s later German-language essay offer a concrete route into this problem. She compares the use of class and race in U.S. and German-language research. She describes the stronger attachment of the German term for class to Marxist traditions of studying inequality. She also explains how the history of Nazi racial politics shapes the use of Rasse in German public life, where it does different work from race categories in U.S. public usage. This is a separate article from 2005. Put it next to the 2000 abstract to ask what an argument must establish before a term can perform the same analytical work elsewhere. Knapp’s 2005 article
Explore another medium
- Books
Feminism without Borders
Chandra Talpade Mohanty
Chandra Talpade Mohanty moves from a critique of the Western gaze to anticapitalist solidarity, grounding transnational feminism in history, labor relations, and shared struggle.
Feminist Theory · Global Feminism - Books
Matters of Care
María Puig de la Bellacasa
A feminist reading of María Puig de la Bellacasa’s account of care as maintenance, affect and political obligation—from knowledge-making to permaculture and living soil.
Feminist Theory · Feminist Epistemology
Continue through the issues
Reader responses
Research discussion
Respond to this research or add another paper worth reading together.
Join the Discussion
Loading comments...
Support Us
If you find our content valuable, please consider supporting FemRes.