FemResThe Living Review

Feminist Theory · Research

What Counts as Feminist Theory

In the first issue of Feminist Theory, Elizabeth Ermarth asks what women learn about competing with one another and what theory can do to those relations.

00

Abstract

Ermarth begins from mutual respect among women and considers how women learn to compete and how theory might act on those relationships.

Keywordsfeminist theorypostmodernismepistemologytheory definitionknowledge boundaries
Read the paper
Share this resource
X ↗Facebook ↗

01

Research notes

Elizabeth Ermarth’s “What Counts as Feminist Theory?” appeared in the inaugural issue of Feminist Theory. Page 113 begins with a set of compressed definitions. Ermarth ties being a feminist to how a woman treats other women, making respect for others a condition of respect for oneself. She then treats theory as thought put to work, whether its work is constructive or subversive. The definitions invite readers to connect the essay’s title to an ordinary situation. Which relations does this idea give us a way to change, and how would we know they had changed?

Where is competition learned?

Ermarth’s examples reach beyond universities and political organizations. She names parents, neighbors, teachers and even school bus drivers among the people through whom girls learn to compete for male attention. The list matters because no single teacher needs to set out to teach competition. Girls can learn through repeated encounters what recognition is worth and why attention given to another girl might feel like their loss. In that setting, respect becomes a question about how recognition and access to resources are distributed. If a woman gains standing in a group, it is worth asking what that standing rewards and whether other women in the group can participate in changing the measures of success.

The opening also gives readers a boundary to examine. Ermarth defines women through cultural marking while placing narrow qualifications on biological sex and age. Her definition of feminist excludes male allies. These are terms of her intervention in 2000. They make it possible to ask what a definition centered on relations among women brings into focus and where it leaves different experiences hard to see, including differences between how people are categorized, how they are treated and how they understand themselves.

Putting respect first also changes what counts as a public issue. Where school, neighborhood and family reward women for holding one another in contempt, a kind encounter changes that moment. A change in the relationship would also show up in who can step away from the competition and what it costs to do so.

Read across the inaugural issue

Read the opening alongside pages 97–99 of Sara Ahmed’s “Whose Counting?” in the same issue. Ermarth begins with how people treat one another. Ahmed asks who does the counting and considers how courses, bookshelves and academic settings grant recognition to some forms of work. Try placing a work normally assigned in a theory course beside one filed under a different label. Which relations does each seek to change, and how does its label affect who encounters it? Bronwyn Winter’s dictionary exercise adds another response from the issue, turning to conventions for making definitions. The three pieces give readers different places to examine the same question.

Reader responses

Research discussion

Respond to this research or add another paper worth reading together.

Join the Discussion

Responses

Loading comments...

Support Us

If you find our content valuable, please consider supporting FemRes.

Support FemRes