FemResThe Living Review

Feminist Theory · Research

Who Counts (or Doesn't Count) What as Feminist Theory?: An Exercise in Dictionary Use

Bronwyn Winter starts with the dictionary’s account of theory and asks why readers encounter such different terms when they look up feminism.

00

Abstract

The accessible opening uses the Macquarie Dictionary to connect theory and practice, then examines reluctance to define feminism. This guide follows the first printed page and the author’s public notes.

Keywordsfeminist theoryepistemologyacademic normsknowledge politicsdisciplinary construction
Read the paper
Share this resource
X ↗Facebook ↗

01

Research notes

In Bronwyn Winter’s contribution to Feminist Theory, the dictionary exercise starts with the word theory. Read the journal’s first-page image, page 105, alongside notes 1, 2, 7 and 8 on the article page. The later printed pages require access through the journal. The opening and the notes give readers material they can check directly.

What can a definition of theory help us do?

Note 2 identifies the second edition of the Macquarie Dictionary. On page 105, Winter pulls several elements from its six definitions. Theory conjectures about or explains perceived reality. It concerns principles distinguished from practice or methods that inform practice. It is expected to be coherent. Winter combines these elements into a working definition about explanation and practice. Pause here and try the definition on a text. Which part of someone’s experience does it explain, and what new possibilities for action does it make visible?

The lower half of the page turns to feminism and the reluctance of some introductory works to define it. Winter cites two reasons for that reluctance. One is that a definition might close debate. Another is that people genuinely disagree about the term. Pick a definition and mark the words that specify what needs to change. Can a reader tell which relationship produces the harm and who might have the power to change it? In note 1, Winter acknowledges that she postpones offering her own model, leaving her own writing open to the same test.

What changes when two authors use one term differently?

Note 7 recounts Denise Thompson’s example of one writer using gender ideology for male domination and another reading the same phrase as feminism. Substitute both meanings into a single sentence of criticism and watch its target move. Note 8 questions the U.S. focus of some reference books. Record where the examples in an entry come from, how it defines its key term and whose work it cites. That gives you evidence for assessing the actual reach of the reference.

Read Elizabeth Ermarth’s contribution to the same issue alongside the opening. Compare how the two articles connect theory and practice, then try both accounts on a syllabus that announces what its theory section is for. The exercise makes the discussion of definitions something a reader can repeat with an actual document.

Follow note 8 one step further. Winter values Carol Anne Douglas’s Love & Politics and questions how heavily it draws on the United States. Write down the scope a work promises in its title or introduction, then map where its examples come from. You can credit what it makes accessible while identifying where a reader would need another source.

Reader responses

Research discussion

Respond to this research or add another paper worth reading together.

Join the Discussion

Responses

Loading comments...

Support Us

If you find our content valuable, please consider supporting FemRes.

Support FemRes