FemResThe Living Review

Latin American Feminism · Commentary

Violence and Discrimination against Women and Girls in Latin America and the Caribbean

Standfirst

An Inter-American human-rights report follows girls’ access to justice and a Colombian collective reparations case to ask who gets heard after violence.

FemRes / January 22, 2020
Share this resource
X ↗Facebook ↗

01

Article analysis

How does a girl take part in a case?

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights approved its report on November 14, 2019, and released it on January 22, 2020. Paragraphs 241 to 246 of the full report trace what can happen when girls experience sexual violence. A police or court count only captures cases that reached those institutions. The commission calls for surveys and direct consultation with girls, and asks agencies to account for age, race, ethnicity and socioeconomic position in their records. Those sources can help locate barriers before an incident ever appears as a complaint.

Once a case begins, who can speak on the child’s behalf and help her exercise her own rights? Paragraph 161 of the Inter-American Court’s judgment in V.R.P., V.P.C. et al. v. Nicaragua says the state should provide specialist legal assistance for free, regardless of a parent’s resources or views. The commission also warns that treating girls’ testimony as inherently doubtful or exposing them to an assailant during proceedings can cause further harm. As a companion from a separate setting, Wen Yan’s Angels Wear White invites close attention to the decisions adults make about whose account they will credit.

Who determines what repair looks like?

Paragraphs 66 to 69 turn to survivors of sexual violence in El Salado, Colombia. In decision T-718/17, Colombia’s Constitutional Court directed the responsible agency to ensure the claimants could help identify harms and devise collective reparations under safe and confidential conditions. The commission draws out what that entails. Late notice, rigid participation arrangements and a lack of a secure meeting place can all keep survivors from making decisions even once a reparations programme exists.

Read paragraph 67 of the companion standards and recommendations alongside the case. Restoration of rights and changes to the conditions that sustain violence are part of the work of repair. Look for who actually helped settle on those measures and what support let them do so safely. A tally of closed cases alone leaves both questions open.

02

Continue following this issue

01
Further reading / June 9, 1994

Belém do Pará Convention

Organization of American States (OAS)

02
Further reading / January 9, 2019

Afrodescendent Women in Latin America and the Caribbean: Debts of Equality

Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean

03
Further reading / August 13, 1997

Vishaka: the 1997 workplace harassment judgment

Supreme Court of India

Reader responses

Letters from readers

Respond to this article or add a source that belongs in the discussion.

Join the Discussion

Responses

Loading comments...

Support Us

If you find our content valuable, please consider supporting FemRes.

Support FemRes