FemResThe Living Review
The Furies: Women, Vengeance, and Justice

Anti-Sexual Violence · Books

The Furies: Women, Vengeance, and Justice

AuthorElizabeth Flock

Elizabeth Flock connects a US self-defense case, India’s Green Gang and women’s armed struggle in Syria, asking how protection, force and accountability can come into conflict.

Share this resource
X ↗Facebook ↗

01

Review and reading guide

What does protection mean when the people who need it must also negotiate who is allowed to exercise force? The Furies: Women, Vengeance, and Justice places that question in three different settings. Elizabeth Flock’s 2024 book follows Brittany Smith in Alabama, Angoori Dahariya in Uttar Pradesh and Cicek Mustafa Zibo in Syria. Its comparative structure creates a tension worth retaining: making women’s resistance visible does not establish that every act of force has the same purpose, justification or result.

The book’s publisher record and International Women’s Media Foundation entry identify these three strands. Individual self-defense, a group’s coercive intervention and organized military conflict involve different relationships to power. A useful feminist reading keeps those differences in view rather than turning three people into interchangeable emblems of justified vengeance.

Brittany: evidence and protection are different questions

Flock’s original New Yorker reporting records a rape-kit examination and injuries. Medical evidence existed; its existence did not resolve Brittany’s self-defense claim. This distinction changes the question from the absence of documentation to the power to interpret it.

A medical record, an account of sexual violence and a legal determination about a later use of force address connected but distinct matters. They should not be collapsed into one proposition that either proves everything or matters to nothing. The important issue for this reading is how evidence moves between settings, which parts of an experience become relevant and who decides that relevance.

That approach also resists a misleading assumption about credibility: that a person need only obtain sufficiently persuasive documentation for an institution to provide protection. Records can exist while the response remains contested. Conversely, the absence of a particular record would not by itself settle what happened. The account invites scrutiny of institutional decision-making without pretending that a guide to a book can decide a case or state the present law.

In her interview with SesayArts, Flock discusses the pressure to fit the image of an ideal victim. That frame is useful because it makes the audience’s expectations visible. A person’s history and behavior can be judged against a model of innocence before the circumstances of danger receive attention. The question is who pays for that model and how it shapes what can be heard.

Angoori: collective protection can become control

Angoori Dahariya leads the Green Gang, whose members wear green saris. Flock’s original report documents both assistance and coercive enforcement, including pressure to conform to marriage. That combination requires a more difficult account of solidarity than a story in which a protective group always acts in the interests of the person it claims to protect.

The group’s visibility matters: collective action can change the position of someone who has been expected to negotiate alone. A complaint gains a public audience; the presence of other women can redistribute who must explain themselves. Yet the existence of a collective does not make its judgment automatically fair. The power to intervene includes the power to define the problem, identify the person at fault and decide the acceptable outcome.

The central tension is therefore protection versus autonomy, not simply strength versus weakness. A group can challenge some forms of domination while enforcing other expectations about a woman’s conduct. That does not erase the need that led people to seek help. It asks whether the person receiving help may disagree, refuse the proposed remedy or choose a life that the helpers do not approve.

Reading caste, gender and material insecurity together is more precise than declaring that one woman exists outside every structure of power. Someone denied authority in one setting can acquire authority in another. The relevant questions concern how that authority is exercised, whom it can protect and who may be placed under its control. Admiration for the courage to intervene should not make those questions disappear.

Cicek: military participation does not settle liberation

Cicek Mustafa Zibo’s strand concerns the Women’s Protection Units, the YPJ, in the Syrian conflict. The publisher’s description identifies her as a fighter in an all-female militia that battled ISIS. This setting cannot be treated as a larger version of an individual self-defense case or a community dispute.

An armed organization coordinates people toward political and military aims. The ability of women to participate changes who is visible as a combatant, but it leaves questions about command, obligation, disagreement and the distribution of risk. Access to a role previously denied to women is meaningful without becoming proof that all relations inside that role are equal.

The distinction between representing women and expanding women’s choices is useful here. An image of female strength may become a symbol for a political project while the experiences of particular women remain difficult to express. Reading for agency means attending to what a person can decide, not merely whether she appears in the public picture of resistance. It also means resisting the temptation to treat danger and sacrifice as automatic evidence of emancipation.

The comparative structure can make these questions sharper. It asks what changes when force is exercised by an individual, a local group or a military organization. Those arrangements distribute responsibility differently. Their differences should survive the analogy; otherwise the comparison risks replacing people and institutions with a single dramatic image of women fighting back.

Survival, vengeance and accountability

The subtitle places three terms together without making them equivalent. Survival concerns the possibility of continuing to live; vengeance concerns a response to injury; justice raises questions of authority and accountability. An act may be understood through more than one of these terms, and disagreement about that understanding is part of the book’s readerly problem.

For that reason, recognizing a person’s agency should not require celebrating every consequence of their action. Nor should criticism of an action erase the circumstances in which it became thinkable. A feminist reading can hold those demands together: take the danger seriously, examine the response carefully and ask what conditions would make a greater range of choices available.

The same care applies to the language of institutional failure. Failure creates a need for protection, but it does not confer unlimited authority on whoever promises to provide it. If one source of coercion is replaced by another, the question of accountability remains. Who can contest the protector’s decisions? Who can leave? Who decides whether the promised safety has arrived?

Reading the three strands alongside each other is most valuable when it prevents a simple heroic conclusion. The point is not to decide that force always liberates or that refusing it is always possible. It is to follow the changing relationship between danger, agency and power, while asking how support, resources and accountable institutions could make survival less dependent on extraordinary confrontation.

Explore another medium

Continue through the issues

Reader responses

Readers' notes

Share your reading or add a thread worth following further.

Join the Discussion

Responses

Loading comments...

Support Us

If you find our content valuable, please consider supporting FemRes.

Support FemRes