Disability Justice · Commentary
General Comment No. 5 on living independently and being included in the community
A guide to Article 19 through housing choice, personal assistance and access to public services, with attention to gender and care work.
Article analysis
Suppose a personal assistance service is available only in a designated group home. A resident is free to move, but the help she uses to get out of bed, travel or work cannot go with her. What kind of choice does she have? The UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities offers a way to read that arrangement. Its General Comment No. 5, issued as CRPD/C/GC/5, interprets Article 19 of the Convention. Start with the definitions in paragraph 16 and then use Article 19’s three parts to follow the obligations the Committee sets out.
A place to live, assistance you can direct
Paragraph 16(a) treats independence as choice and control over the details of daily life. Getting up when you want, deciding who can come into your home and choosing when to go out all belong here. So does using extensive daily assistance while keeping control over those decisions. Article 19(a) covers where and with whom people live. Paragraph 16(c) helps explain how an institution’s rules can survive in a small house. Can residents hire or change assistants? Can they turn down a shared assistant? Can they eat or have visitors outside a fixed schedule? These questions reveal what the address and the number of beds cannot.
Article 19(b) concerns access to support, including personal assistance. Read paragraph 16(d) by following the decisions: who selects the provider, directs the work and can change the hours or terms? Someone can handle recruitment directly or delegate administrative tasks while still directing their own assistance. The paragraph also links funding to the provision of decent employment. Both details matter when a provider uses split shifts or has no cover for an absence. A service that relies on a relative dropping everything whenever a shift goes uncovered leaves both the person requesting help and the relative with less control.
Can you use the same bus, clinic or library?
Article 19(c) concerns services and facilities used by the public. They should be available to disabled people on an equal basis and respond to their needs. A person can have an accessible flat and a personal assistant and still miss work if the bus has no usable boarding arrangement. Someone who gets to a clinic may have no practical way to communicate there. Try following a single trip in that order to see which part of the right is missing. Liat Ben-Moshe’s Decarcerating Disability offers a companion question: as support moves out of a large institution, which practices of control move with it?
When leaving also means losing support
Paragraphs 72–74 connect Article 19 to the rights of disabled women and girls. The Committee describes how paternalism can constrain where women live, and how an abuser may also be the person they depend on for physical or financial support. Consider what leaving entails on a particular evening. Is there accessible transport? Can the refuge communicate with her and arrange the assistance she needs when she gets there? What happens the next morning? Bring in General Comment No. 3 to read access to support, freedom from violence and authority over decisions together.
For a concrete reading exercise, make three columns for housing, assistance and public services. Ask whether support can follow a move, who sets the working hours of assistance, and what can actually be reached. Add a place to record who pays or works extra when the arrangement breaks down. This brings the lives of the people receiving and providing support into the same account of what makes a choice possible. UN document in English
Explore another medium
- Books
Decarcerating Disability
Liat Ben-Moshe
Liat Ben-Moshe connects deinstitutionalization with prison abolition, challenging the claim that closing institutions caused mass incarceration.
Disability Justice - Films
Crip Camp: A Disability Revolution
Nicole Newnham, Jim LeBrecht
Camp Jened’s conversations about privacy and the work of feeding a 1977 sit-in show how disabled organizers made participation possible.
Disability Justice · Human Rights
Continue through the issues
Included in · No. 15
Who gets to live on their own terms?
Thirty works on who gets to decide how to live and who sustains those choices, from a crowded train to a federal sit-in.
Disability Justice · Bodily Autonomy
Related theme · No. 03
Who gets to define the body?
From discipline and ageing to the internalised gaze, this issue follows the forces that watch, name and reclaim the body.
Bodily Autonomy
Reader responses
Letters from readers
Respond to this article or add a source that belongs in the discussion.
Join the Discussion
Loading comments...
Support Us
If you find our content valuable, please consider supporting FemRes.