FemResThe Living Review
Crip Camp: A Disability Revolution

Disability Justice · Screen

Crip Camp: A Disability Revolution

Camp Jened’s conversations about privacy and the work of feeding a 1977 sit-in show how disabled organizers made participation possible.

Director
Nicole Newnham, Jim LeBrecht
Year
2020
Region
USA
Duration
106 min · Netflix’s public upload
Share this resource
X ↗Facebook ↗

Reading the film

At Camp Jened, counselor Judy Heumann tries to settle what the campers will eat. Even the suggestion of lasagna provokes disagreement. This is a small scene worth staying with. People whose activities are frequently planned for them are weighing a menu, dating and deciding when they want to be left alone. In 1971 the community video group People’s Video Theater brought portable recording equipment to the camp in upstate New York. Nicole Newnham and Jim LeBrecht, himself a former camper, set the resulting black-and-white footage beside later interviews and records of disability rights organizing. The alternation between sources changes whose point of view the audience encounters first.

Making room to speak and to be alone

Around 32 minutes in, the campers start talking about parents. The teenage LeBrecht says his mother orders the supplies he needs. He worries that if he pushes back too often, she may become reluctant to help. A girl says that her two brothers, close to her in age, have much more freedom. The film also gives Nancy Rosenblum nearly a minute to speak about why it is so hard for her to get time alone. Read the discussion alongside Mia Mingus’s “Forced Intimacy”. Mingus helps put a name to what can be demanded in exchange for access, from disclosing private details to accepting help from someone you would not have chosen.

The camp footage makes room for jokes, complaints and disagreement. The opening also shows how portable video gave campers a means to participate in making the record. Compare these images with the footage made to show disabled people to a charitable audience or to document a segregated institution. Who gets to pick the subject of a conversation? Who gets a turn behind the camera? The interviews also remember a hierarchy among disabled people. Jened gave particular young people room to do things differently, and the film lets us see some of the exclusions and disagreements that remained.

What kept the sit-in going overnight?

By the time of the 1977 sit-ins, Section 504 of the U.S. Rehabilitation Act of 1973 was already law. Protesters wanted federal officials to sign the regulations needed to enforce it. In the San Francisco sequence, around 1:08, participants remember trying to get food and blankets and work out how they would wash. Disabled organizer and Black Panther Brad Lomax suggested contacting the Panthers. Corbett O’Toole recalls that they brought a hot meal and left food for breakfast and lunch. Notice the time scale of that account. Enough food to get through tonight and into tomorrow is one of the things that makes a prolonged occupation possible.

A feminist viewing can follow public negotiation and the work that makes it possible in the same sequence. Heumann’s leadership receives sustained attention. So does a cross-movement alliance that helps people eat and stay. Ask who is positioned to speak for a coalition, who notices what the room needs and who cannot get into that room in the first place. Sins Invalid’s ten principles of disability justice give those questions a vocabulary of interdependence and collective access, while keeping this film’s particular American history in view.

Follow those questions out of the building

Pair the film with UN General Comment No. 5. Its discussion of housing, personal assistance and community services lets you track what would have to change for choices to become practical. A camper who wants privacy needs some control over the arrangement of support. Protesters who want to remain in a federal office need a way to meet immediate needs. In both settings the question of who decides is inseparable from who can put a decision into effect. Netflix’s official full feature · Film curriculum

Reader responses

Discussion

Share your response and continue the reading together.

Join the Discussion

Responses

Loading comments...

Support Us

If you find our content valuable, please consider supporting FemRes.

Support FemRes